RoofViews

Building Science

The Role of Thermal Inertia in Low-Slope Roof Design

By Thomas J Taylor

September 10, 2020

Sun-drenched Thera.

Is thermal mass a lost art form after centuries of use in temperate regions?

In building design, the thermal mass of a building enables it to store heat, providing "inertia" against temperature fluctuations. It reduces the impact of external daily temperature swings on internal heating and cooling requirements. This thermal inertia has been an on-off again topic of discussion for some time. Proponents of adding thermal inertia point to Mediterranean area buildings constructed with thick stone walls and ceramic tile floors etc. Such buildings have kept occupants cooler than lighter weight buildings in many temperate areas of the world for centuries. In the quest to improve the energy efficiency of buildings, further gains are becoming increasingly harder to come by.

  • Code requirements for increased thermal insulation in the US have reached the point of rapidly diminishing rates of return.
  • The use of highly reflective roof membranes has become widespread, with white or light-colored thermoplastic single-ply now representing over 60% of roof coverings installed each year.
  • Airtightness of buildings, achieved with an air barrier around the entire building envelope, has been improved significantly over the past decade and further improvements will be increasingly harder to obtain.

This article explores how the thermal inertia of low-slope roofs can be a factor in improving thermal efficiency when considering building geometry, climate, and use.

Introduction

It is helpful to review the role of each part of a roof assembly in terms of its effect on energy efficiency, beginning at the top portion that directly faces the sun and sky. There are two main effects that building envelope materials have on thermal energy (i.e. heat) transmission that are explored here.

  • Thermal resistance, which is a measure of the extent to which a material blocks or resists heat transfer. Building designers and construction professionals are very familiar with this and R-value, a numerical description of the extent to which a material can resist heat flow.
  • Time delay of heat transfer, or the extent to which a material slows down or delays heat transfer. As will be seen, a material can have low thermal resistance but still delay heat transfer. This is the crux of the terms "thermal mass" and "thermal inertia".

Solar Heat Energy Impacting Roof Surface

It should be fairly clear that the peak of the sun's heat impact on a roof is around 1pm, and has lower impact in the early morning and late evening hours. This is shown in the following schematic:


  • The amount of the sun's energy reaching the roof shown above peaks at around 1pm. For this reason, power output from solar panels is maximized at that time.
  • Rooftop surface temperatures are at their highest at around 1pm.
  • The amount of solar energy at midday in June, when the sun is at its' highest, is about 1 kW/m2 in the southern US. This is considerable and is why energy efficiency efforts focused on air conditioning demand are so important.

Impact of Reflective Membranes

Highly reflective roof membranes such as TPO and PVC are capable of reflecting well over 60% of the sun's energy (see CRRC rated products directory for actual values). For a roof with zero insulation, this would have the effect of reducing the amount of solar heat energy moving through the roof into the building, as shown here:


  • The energy entering the building is reduced because some is reflected off the roof surface by a reflective membrane such as TPO or PVC.
  • The peak energy flow through a membrane coincides with the sun's highest point, around 1pm.

Impact of Reflective Membranes and Insulation

When insulation such as polyiso is installed beneath a highly reflective membrane, it further reduces the amount of solar energy entering a building, as shown below:


  • The heat energy entering the building is further reduced by the insulation.
  • Importantly, there is a small time delay and the peak energy flow into the building is after the sun has already passed its highest point in the sky.

Building codes have steadily increased the amount of insulation required. However, each additional unit of insulation added is less effective than the previous units. This is shown in the following chart:


  • Further gains in energy efficiency through the use of more roof insulation are becoming less and less cost-effective due to the law of diminishing returns.
  • Greater thicknesses of insulation cause difficulties with respect to perimeter, parapet wall, and penetration heights. Insulation technologies with greater resistance per inch of thickness, like aerogels and vacuum insulated panels, have not yet proven to be widely cost-effective in roofing applications.
  • Energy efficiency improvement efforts have recently focused on creating an air barrier around the entire building enclosure in large part due to the limitations in adding more and more insulation. By having the building enclosure perform as an air barrier, conditioned air is retained within the structure.
  • Most considerations of a roof assembly primarily consider membrane, insulation and, when used, cover boards. However, given that cover boards are typically thin and therefore of low mass, it is the roof deck that offers the best chance of increasing thermal inertia.

Impact of Roof Deck

The roof deck is frequently taken for granted and not discussed as part of the roof assembly. However, it can make a contribution to energy-efficiency as discussed here. The following schematic shows two very similar roof assemblies. However, the left-hand design is on a steel deck while the right-hand system is over a concrete deck.


  • Both systems have two layers of polyiso with staggered and offset joints to reduce heat flow.
  • The steel deck system above has a mechanically attached first layer of polyiso. By minimizing the thickness of this first layer, the fasteners can be buried within the system to reduce thermal bridging.

Due to its metallic nature and relative thinness, the steel deck has essentially no effect on energy efficiency.

  • A roof assembly on a steel deck will generally have the same heat flux into the building as shown above for the membrane and insulation only.
  • The thin steel deck doesn't absorb any significant amount of heat and it has almost zero thermal resistance.

A concrete deck has what is known as "thermal mass", providing inertia to any heat flow. This results in a slowing of the heat flux into a building as shown below:


  • A concrete deck significantly slows the transmission of heat down into a building but it doesn't necessarily have a high thermal resistance (lightweight insulating concrete is a special case and will be covered in a future article).
  • During multi-day cycles, thermal inertia tends to dampen out temperature swings as shown in the following chart:


  • By dampening out temperature swings, thermal inertia can increase thermal comfort within a building enclosure. If this effect is coordinated with the mechanical designer it can also help reduce upfront HVAC equipment sizing and costs that would have otherwise been designed to offset higher peak energy loads. (Of course, energy cost savings are not guaranteed and the amount of savings may vary based on climate zone, utility rates, radiative properties of roofing products, insulation levels, HVAC equipment efficiency and other factors.)
  • Importantly, thermal inertia does not change the area under the heat flux curves. Looking at the plot above, the low points for a thermal mass assembly are higher than the assembly without thermal mass.

Thermal Inertia and Energy Efficiency

As noted in the beginning, thermal inertia has been incorporated in Mediterranean building practice and has kept buildings cool during summer periods. However, a close analysis reveals that while temperature swings are reduced and thermal comfort increased, energy-efficiency of air-conditioned buildings aren't necessarily improved.

There have been many published modeling exercises that have examined the long term energy-efficiency of building enclosures that incorporate significant amounts of thermal inertia

  • All studies show that materials with high thermal inertia are best installed on the inner side of a building enclosure and insulation on the outer side. So, low slope roof assemblies with the membrane at the top, over insulation, and a concrete deck at the bottom, would meet this.
  • While many studies claim to show improvements in building energy-efficiency when thermal inertia of the building envelope is increased, there are as many studies showing that there is no long-term effect
  • A comprehensive review of published studies has suggested that the large differences in outcomes are a result of differences in assumed building usage, thermostat controls and settings, climate, and building geometry and location.

Examination of many peer-reviewed studies suggests the following:

  • Thermal inertia has a small or insignificant effect on heating efficiency.
  • For buildings occupied around the clock, thermal inertia is unlikely to affect overall energy-efficiency regardless of climate. However, it may improve thermal comfort by reducing the magnitude of thermal swings.
  • For buildings that are only occupied during daylight hours, such as office buildings, increasing thermal inertia could move peak cooling demand into late afternoon and evening hours.

    • If setback thermostats were employed, this could result in a reduction in cooling costs and an improvement in thermal comfort.
    • In larger buildings with variable speed HVAC fans, the system could drop to a lower speed during evening hours, thereby lowering energy use.

  • For thermal inertia to be an important factor in roofing design, such as for office buildings which are only used during daylight hours, the roof area would have to be a significant part of the building enclosure. In other words, the use of thermal inertia to lower energy use would be more appropriate for low rise buildings.

Characterizing the Effects of Thermal Inertia

There are two key characteristics of thermal inertia; the decrement factor and time delay, both of which can be readily modeled and experimentally verified. A schematic showing these is shown below:


The time delay is calculated as:

formula for thermal inertia


  • The time delay and decrement factor could be used by building designers to better optimize thermostat specification. As noted earlier, a large time delay could significantly reduce daily AC cooling demands and peak loads for office buildings.
  • Larger decrement factors can improve occupants' thermal comfort.

Conclusions

  • Increasing the thermal inertia of roofing systems could be beneficial in regions where air conditioning dominates versus heating.
  • Thermal inertia can be increased by using concrete decks. In fact, modeling suggests that when adding thermal mass to a building enclosure ensuring the mass is on the interior and continuous insulation is to the outside is the only way to potentially improve energy-efficiency. A design professional should be consulted to determine whether a concrete deck is appropriate on a given project.
  • On a longer-term basis (over 48 hour periods) for buildings used 24 hours a day, increasing thermal inertia is unlikely to improve energy-efficiency. Increased thermal inertia dampens temperature swings and peak demand loads, but the overall heat flux isn't reduced significantly.
  • Adding thermal mass could be advantageous for buildings occupied during daylight hours only. These would include schools and office buildings for example. By delaying heat flux down into those buildings, energy usage could be reduced so long as set-back thermostat control or similar ways to reduce energy usage during unoccupied hours are used. These could include reducing variable speed HVAC fans to a slower set point during evening hours. A design professional should be consulted to determine appropriate ways to add thermal mass on a given project.

Note – diagrams and charts shown in this article are not to scale and are for illustration of key points only.

Sources Used

  1. Verbeke, S., Thermal inertia in dwellings. Quantifying the relative effects of building thermal mass on energy use and overheating risk in a temperate climate. PhD Thesis, University of Antwerp, 2017.
  2. Balaji, N. C., Mani, M., and Venkatarama, R. B. V., Thermal performance of building walls. 1st IBPSA Italy Conference, Building Simulation, 2013, pp. 151 – 159.
  3. D'Orazio, M., Di Perna, C., and Di Giuseppe, E., A field study of thermal inertia of roofs and its influence on indoor comfort. J. Building Physics, 38, 2013, pp. 50 – 65.
  4. Kossecka, E. and Kosny, J., Influence of insulation configuration on heating and cooling loads in a continuously used building. Energy and Buildings, 34, 2002, pp. 321 – 331.
  5. Wang, D., Yu, W., Zhao, X., Dai, W., and Ruan, Y., The influence of thermal insulation position in building exterior walls on indoor thermal comfort and energy consumption of residential buildings in Chongqing. IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 40, 2016

About the Author

Thomas J Taylor, PhD is the Building & Roofing Science Advisor for GAF. Tom has over 20 year’s experience in the building products industry, all working for manufacturing organizations. He received his PhD in chemistry from the University of Salford, England, and holds approximately 35 patents. Tom’s main focus at GAF is roofing system design and building energy use reduction. Under Tom’s guidance GAF has developed TPO with unmatched weathering resistance.

Related Articles

Roofers install a GAF EverGuard PVC roofing system.
Commercial Roofing

How PVC Experts Can Help Design Specialized Roofing Projects

With the growing popularity and versatility of PVC roofing systems, GAF has responded by building a team of PVC experts to aid architects, specifiers, and the design community in project success. These highly trained and experienced professionals offer 1:1 support to help answer customers' questions and unique needs when working with PVC on roofing projects, and are here to help you!PVC, or polyvinyl chloride, is a single-ply thermoplastic roofing membrane. The material's characteristics help it thrive in particularly challenging applications. In fact, PVC roofing systems have a proven track record in the US, first introduced in the 1970s after making their debut in Germany a decade earlier.Here's a look at the benefits of PVC roofing systems as well as the guidance and support offered by the PVC experts at GAF.PVC Roofing Advantages and ApplicationsWhile several materials are available for use in roofing systems, PVC has been identified as a particularly long-lasting option. Accordingly, it's steadily grown in popularity nationwide.David Allor, senior area PVC specialist, joined the GAF team in 2022 as a PVC expert. His role was created specifically to support roof designers. Allor has an extensive background in the commercial roofing industry and extensive knowledge about PVC as a high-performance roofing solution."The industry refers to it as a very spec-driven product, and I believe what they're speaking to is a specifier's preference to work with a product that's been well established in the market and field tested," Allor shares. "It has the ability to provide protection against chemical exposure* and stand up well to challenging environments."While PVC may be a spec-driven product, it's also application-driven. Allor explains that PVC roofs may help provide protection for restaurants, food manufacturers, and packaging plants—any facility using animal fats where oils may be exhausted.* He also says that even if the building itself isn't exhausting gases, grease, or chemicals, it's important to consider the buildings and structures that surround it, as their exteriors may be subjected to exhaust that could degrade roofing systems.*Supporting the Design CommunityAs North America's largest roofing materials manufacturer, GAF has equipped teams with the resources and specialists needed to supply customers with more than just products. In recent years, the company built a solid team of PVC specialists that cover the entire US. These specialists assist customers with PVC specifications, roof system designs, and whatever else designers need to ensure successful project outcomes.Whether your project or design firm is based in the Northeast, Southeast, Southwest, Midwest, or West Coast, a PVC specialist is positioned to help. Allor explains the team of GAF PVC specialists is active in the organizations specifiers belong to, including the American Institute of Architects, the Construction Specifications Institute, and the International Institute of Building Enclosure Consultants.Allor describes the team's role as supporting the customer and connecting them to other GAF project support teams that can help. For instance, he said he called on a leading architectural design firm in the Boston area—and two months later, someone reached out for assistance with a specific project needing a tight turnaround."Literally within 12 hours of them reaching out to us, we replied and committed to three pertinent deliverables, those being a Tapered ISO Design Package, an Assembly Letter confirming all FM Requirements, and last but not least, a conference call the next day with the Building and Roofing Science team to go over three critical transitional details." Allor says.Committing to Successful Project OutcomesThe PVC specialists at GAF are focused on one goal: helping architects, specifiers, and the roofing design community achieve successful project outcomes through a high-performing PVC roofing system. With professionals like Allor providing insight and guidance, you can rest assured your PVC project will be in good hands.Ready to get started on your next PVC roofing project? Explore the different PVC roofing solutions available, and visit this page to find your local PVC roofing specialist who is ready to assist you.*GAF warranties and guarantees do not provide coverage against exposure to chemicals, grease, oils, animal fats or exhaust. Refer to gaf.com for more information on warranty and guarantee coverage and restrictions.

By Authors Karen L Edwards

April 22, 2024

Schoolyard with basketball court and school building exterior in the sunny evening. School yard with
Commercial Roofing

Branching Out into Commercial Roof Maintenance for Schools

Commercial roof maintenance programs are a great way to expand your business and build long-term relationships with school facility managers. You may already be offering commercial roof maintenance services, or perhaps you're interested in branching out. Providing roof maintenance to K-12 schools and universities can be a good source of reliable, ongoing work. But you'll need to consider these facilities' nuances.Schools' Current Roof Maintenance ChallengesIn an educational environment, students' safety and comfort come first. Buildings must be secure and functional, and they must provide an atmosphere conducive to learning. Creating this environment starts with the roof, but this can easily be put off or forgotten about as many school facility managers focus on day-to-day maintenance issues. If students and teachers complain about a lack of hot water or classroom temperatures that are too hot or cold, facility managers swiftly address these issues.However, facility managers should prioritize regular roof maintenance in addition to addressing the most immediate facility concerns. Even something like a small leak from deferred roof maintenance can lead to much larger, and more costly repairs, creating headaches for everyone involved, that could have been avoided.The Value of Commercial Roof Maintenance ProgramsThe roof protects everything inside the school—from books and computers to shop equipment and musical instruments. If a roof leaks, many items could suffer damage. At the end of the day, ensuring a quality roof through regular maintenance not only protects everything inside the building, it can also help extend the life of the roof. Moreover, some roofing system manufacturers may require regular roof inspections to maintain warranties or guarantees. A roof maintenance program can meet this requirement, providing inspection records and evidence that any issues were addressed.How to Develop a Maintenance Program for SchoolsA commercial roof maintenance program for schools isn't much different from what you already do for other commercial buildings. And while regular maintenance inspections can be completed anytime, a neglected roof can often end up requiring repairs that need to align with the school's calendar to plan for minimal disruptions to the students. This can cause inconvenient delays, or date changes that could be avoided with regular inspections and maintenance.GAF Senior Product Manager Benjamin Runyan says that it's important to identify the manufacturer of the existing roofing system to ensure you are using compatible products that won't void the warranty or guarantee. "You want to be looking at this from a maintenance standpoint," says Runyan. "What does the roof look like? How was it built? How have they been maintaining it?"To start, Runyan recommends that you inspect the entire roof system and document its condition with photos and notes. Pay particular attention to the more vulnerable areas, such as seams, fasteners, flashings, edge metal, drains, and gutters. Look for cracks, missing roofing materials, evidence of ponding water, or of birds or other animals, and signs of moss or algae. An infrared scan of the roof can determine if any moisture is present and help pinpoint areas that need immediate attention.Your program should include basic tasks such as clearing debris from drains and gutters, removing leaves or branches, and making minor repairs where existing sealants are losing pliability or are showing signs of deterioration. If you identify larger concerns, you can document that with photos and provide an estimate for the repairs. Also, note how long the repairs should take and what products you'll use.Getting Started with SchoolsPreventative maintenance programs aren't just a benefit to the schools, they can also lead to other school roofing work including re-roofing opportunities. If you're ready to add school commercial maintenance programs to your business plan, GAF has the resources you need to get started. Runyan explains, "Your first step should be talking with your GAF Territory Manager as they will likely already have established relationships with school districts, colleges, roof consultants and architects in your service area."From commercial roofing system specifications to WellRoof® Guarantee Extensions, plus roof restoration options, GAF meets all your needs for stepping into the world of educational buildings.

By Authors Karen L Edwards

March 06, 2024

An aerial shot of the student housing building on the Texas A&M campus.
Building Science

Are Hybrid Roof Assemblies Worth the Hype?

How can roofing assemblies contribute to a building's energy efficiency, resiliency, and sustainability goals? Intentional material selection will increase the robustness of the assembly including the ability to weather a storm, adequate insulation will assist in maintaining interior temperatures and help save energy, and more durable materials may last longer, resulting in less frequent replacements. Hybrid roof assemblies are the latest roofing trend aimed at contributing to these goals, but is all the hype worth it?What is a hybrid roof assembly?A hybrid roof assembly is where two roofing membranes, composed of different technologies, are used in one roof system. One such assembly is where the base layers consist of asphaltic modified bitumen, and the cap layer is a reflective single-ply membrane such as a fleece-back TPO or PVC. Each roof membrane is chosen for their strengths, and together, the system combines the best of both membranes. A hybrid system such as this has increased robustness, with effectively two plies or more of membrane.Asphaltic membranes, used as the first layer, provide redundancy and protection against punctures as it adds overall thickness to the system. Asphaltic systems, while having decades of successful roof installations, without a granular surface may be vulnerable to UV exposure, have minimal resistance to ponding water or certain chemical contaminants, and are generally darker in color options as compared to single ply surfacing colors choices. The addition of a single-ply white reflective membrane will offset these properties, including decreasing the roof surface temperatures and potentially reducing the building's heat island effect as they are commonly white or light in color. PVC and KEE membranes may also provide protection where exposure to chemicals is a concern and generally hold up well in ponding water conditions. The combination of an asphaltic base below a single-ply system increases overall system thickness and provides protection against punctures, which are primary concerns with single-ply applications.Pictured Above: EverGuard® TPO 60‑mil Fleece‑Back MembraneOlyBond 500™ AdhesiveRUBEROID® Mop Smooth MembraneMillennium Hurricane Force ® 1-Part Membrane AdhesiveDensDeck® Roof BoardMillennium Hurricane Force ® 1-Part Membrane AdhesiveEnergyGuard™ Polyiso InsulationMillennium Hurricane Force ® 1-Part Membrane AdhesiveConcrete DeckPictured Above: EverGuard® TPO 60‑mil Fleece‑Back MembraneGAF LRF Adhesive XF (Splatter)RUBEROID® HW Smooth MembraneDrill‑Tec™ Fasteners & PlatesDensDeck® Prime Gypsum BoardEnergyGuard™ Polyiso InsulationEnergyGuard™ Polyiso InsulationGAF SA Vapor Retarder XLMetal DeckWhere are hybrid roof assemblies typically utilized?Hybrid roof assemblies are a common choice for K-12 & higher education buildings, data centers, and hospitals due to their strong protection against leaks and multi-ply system redundancy. The redundancy of the two membrane layers provides a secondary protection against leaks if the single-ply membrane is breached. Additionally, the reflective single-ply membrane can result in lower rooftop temperatures. The addition of a reflective membrane over a dark-colored asphaltic membrane will greatly increase the Solar Reflectance Index (SRI) of the roof surface. SRI is an indicator of the ability of a surface to return solar energy into the atmosphere. In general, roof material surfaces with a higher SRI will be cooler than a surface with a lower SRI under the same solar energy exposure. A lower roof surface temperature can result in less heat being absorbed into the building interior during the summer months.Is a hybrid only for new construction?The advantage of a hybrid roof assembly is significant in recover scenarios where there is an existing-modified bitumen or built-up roof that is in overall fair condition and with little underlying moisture present. A single ply membrane can be installed on top of the existing roof system without an expensive and disruptive tear-off of the existing assembly. The addition of the single-ply membrane adds reflectivity to the existing darker colored membrane and increases the service life of the roof assembly due to the additional layer of UV protection. Additionally, the single-ply membrane can be installed with low VOC options that can have minimum odor and noise disturbance if construction is taking place while the building is occupied.Is the hybrid assembly hype worth it?Absolutely! The possibility to combine the best aspects of multiple roofing technologies makes a hybrid roof assembly worth the hype. It provides the best aspects of a single-ply membrane including a reflective surface for improved energy efficiency, and increased protection against chemical exposure and ponding water, while the asphaltic base increases overall system waterproofing redundancy, durability and protection. The ability to be used in both new construction and recover scenarios makes a multi-ply hybrid roof an assembly choice that is here to stay.Interested in learning more about designing school rooftops? Check out available design resources school roof design resources here. And as always, feel free to reach out to the Building & Roofing Science team with questions.This article was written by Kristin M. Westover, P.E., LEED AP O+M, Technical Manager, Specialty Installations, in partnership with Benjamin Runyan, Sr. Product Manager - Asphalt Systems.

By Authors Kristin Westover

December 28, 2023

Don't miss another GAF RoofViews post!

Subscribe now